Table 2.

Quality Features of Articles Included for Review

SourceRandomizedDouble- BlindedDescription of DropoutsDesignDescription of Allocation ConcealmentPower AnalysisIntention to Treat
RCT = randomized controlled trial.
Charles et al,12 2000YesYesYesRCTIndeterminantYesYes
Charles et al,13 1998YesYesYesRCTIndeterminantNoNo
Fontbonne et al,14 1996YesYesYesRCTIndeterminantYesYes
Guigliano et al,15 1993YesYesYesCrossoverIndeterminantYesNo dropouts
Kantola et al,16 2002YesYesYesRCTYesYesNo
Lawson et al,17 1970YesYesYesCrossoverIndeterminantNoNo
Lehtovorta et al,18 2001YesYesYesRCTIndeterminantYesNo dropouts
More et al,19 1999YesYesYesCrossoverIndeterminantNoYes
Paolisso et al,20 1998YesYesYesRCTIndeterminantNoNo dropouts