Summary of Variables
Variable | Baseline Estimate | Range Used in Sensitivity Analysis | Source |
---|---|---|---|
EIA = enzyme immunosorbent assay; HIV = human immunodeficiency virus; PHI = primary HIV infection; CBC = complete blood count; G6PD = glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase; CMV = cytomegalovirus; RPR = rapid plasma reagin; PPD = purified protein derivative (tuberculin); NAAT = nucleic acid amplification test. | |||
* Initial battery of laboratory tests includes: CBC, chemistry panel, G6PD assay, toxoplasmosis titer, CMV titer, RPR, PPD skin test, viral hepatitis panel, lipid panel, urinalysis, chest radiograph, urine NAAT for gonorrhea and chlamydia. | |||
Costs ($) | |||
p24 antigen EIA | 24.65 | 12.33–49.30 | Medicare fee schedule |
HIV-1 RNA assay | 118.89 | 59.45–237.78 | Medicare fee schedule |
Third-generation HIV-1 EIA | 19.17 | 9.59–38.34 | Medicare fee schedule |
Western blot assay | 27.05 | 13.53–54.10 | Medicare fee schedule |
CD4 cell count per microliter | 90 | 45–180 | Medicare fee schedule |
Initial battery of laboratorys tests (new diagnosis)* | 254 | 200–614 | Medicare fee schedule |
Expanded testing program costs | 101.47 | 51–203 | MMWR20 |
Discounted lifetime medical costs (diagnosed with PHI and antiretroviral therapy started at CD4 cell count of 350/μL) | 95,800 | 47,900–191,600 | Freedberg et al23 |
Discounted lifetime medical costs (PHI not diagnosed and antiretroviral therapy started when HIV diagnosed) | 88,100 | 44,050–176,200 | Freedberg et al23 |
Return visit | 52.53 | 40–67.86 | Kaplan & Anderson24 |
Test characteristics | |||
p24 antigen EIA, sensitivity | 0.887 | 0.770–0.957 | Hecht et al,8 Daar et al9 |
Specificity | 0.9996 | 0.9950–0.9999 | Hecht et al,8 Daar et al9 |
HIV-1 RNA, sensitivity | 1.000 | — | Hecht et al,8 Daar et al9 |
Specificity | 0.980 | 0.950–0.999 | Hecht et al,8 Daar et al9 |
Third-generation HIV-1 EIA, sensitivity | 0.790 | 0.600–0.920 | Hecht et al8 |
Specificity | 0.970 | 0.930–0.990 | Hecht et al8 |
Probability of indeterminate Western blot | 0.000004 | — | Kleinman et al22 |
Prevalence factors (%) | |||
Patients lost to follow-up | 31 | 16–62 | MMWR21 |
Prevalence in screened population | 0.66 | 0.53–0.92 | Coco & Kleinhans16 |
Sexual transmission factors | |||
Patients who change behavior to avoid infecting sexual partner | 50 | 0–96 | MMWR6 |
Patients that are sexually active | 50 | 25–85 | MMWR6 |
Infectivity (probability of sexual transmission during PHI period) | 15 | 0–30 | Yerly et al,25 Pilcher et al26 |
Utilities | |||
Asymptomatic HIV infection | 0.937 | 0.926–0.949 | Schackman et al27 |
Anxiety while waiting for confirmatory test results for patients with a positive screen | 0.682 | 0.400–0.800 | Kaplan & Anderson24 |
Quality-adjusted life-expectancy (discounted), years | |||
No PHI | 24 | — | NCHS15 |
Positive screening result, no PHI | 23.9735 | 23.950–23.983 | NCHS,15 Kaplan & Anderson24 |
PHI diagnosed at screening with follow-up care and antiretroviral treatment started at CD4 cell count of 350/μL | 11.9 | 11.832–11.952 | Freedberg et al23 |
PHI not diagnosed at screening or lost to care with antiretroviral treatment started when HIV diagnosed | 11 | — | Freedberg et al23 |