Table 4

Advantages and Disadvantages of Split-Session Focus Groups and Traditional Focus Groups

Focus Group ApproachAdvantagesDisadvantages
Split sessionFits into existing practice workflow
Generates dialog and interaction among the full group
Allows gathering of data from distinct subgroups having different perspectives
Permits staff and physicians to speak freely without the other present
Allows recruitment of more participants for each session
Nets an overall cost savings
Requires that practice must be willing to accommodate focus group interviews at their location
Necessitates a conference room, waiting room, or other suitable area be available on site to conduct sessions
Limits time with subgroups, which may yield less rich data
Traditional (unsplit)Allows ability to conduct multiple groups at one time
Enables bringing together participants from multiple practices at once
Yields lower participation rates
Requires participants to travel to location
May constrain staff and physicians from speaking freely when other is present
May require additional incentives