Table 3

Adjusted Patient Expenditures and Hospitalizations for Primary Care Physicians

Expenditures (natural log)
All Primary Care PhysiciansFamily PhysiciansGeneral Internists
β (95% CI)P Valueβ (95% CI)P Valueβ (95% CI)P Value
Training HSA spending categorya
 LowReferenceReferenceReference
 Average0.02
(−0.02 to 0.06)
.270.03
(−0.03 to 0.09)
.320.01
(−0.05 to 0.07)
.71
 High0.11
(0.06–0.15)
<.0010.11
(0.05–0.17)
<.0010.10
(0.04–0.16)
<.001
Practice HSA spending category
 Low ($6,102 to $8,683)ReferenceReferenceReference
 Average ($8,691 to $9,879)0.05
(0.01–0.09)
.020.03
(−0.03 to 0.09)
.260.07
(0.01–0.14)
.02
 High ($9,880 to $16,542)0.08
(0.04–0.13)
<.0010.07
(0.01–0.13)
.030.11
(0.05–0.17)
<.001
Number of physicians3,0751,3981,677
Number of beneficiaries502,920268,595234,325
Hospitalization (yes = 1, no = 0)
All PC PhysiciansFamily PhysiciansGeneral Internists
OR (95% CI)P ValueOR (95% CI)P ValueOR (95% CI)P Value
Training HSA spending categorya
 LowReferenceReferenceReference
 Average1.05
(0.99–1.12)
.111.04
(0.96–1.13)
.341.04
(0.94–1.15)
.46
 High0.97
(0.90–1.04)
.361.00
(0.91–1.11)
.940.93
(0.84–1.03)
.18
Practice HSA spending category
 Low ($6,102 to $8,683)ReferenceReferenceReference
 Average ($8,691 to $9,879)1.00
(0.93–1.08)
.941.03
(0.94–1.13)
.510.98
(0.87–1.11)
.80
 High ($9,880 to $16,542)1.03
(0.95–1.11)
.491.09
(0.99–1.19)
.070.99
(0.88–1.10)
.82
Number of physicians3,0751,3981,677
Number of beneficiaries502,920268,595234,325
  • HSA = Hospital Service Area

  • Note: Data are based on 2011 Medicare Claims. Data are weighted and restricted to primary care physicians with 1–19 years of practice and 40 or more Medicare patients, excluding patients with total expenditures greater than $100,000.

  • a To standardize training HSA spending, we calculated a standardized z score for HSA spending for each year between 1992 and 2010. The training HSA spending groups are Low: −1.49 to −0.14; Average: −0.13 to 0.46; High: 0.48 – 4.50. Each group has approximately the same number of beneficiaries.