Table 1

Demographic Composition of the Expert Panel

CharacteristicNo. (%)
Background
 Evidence-based medicine expert22 (55)
 Guideline developer17 (42.5)
 Consumer representative1 (2.5)
Sex
 Male26 (65)
 Female14 (35)
Self-identified background
 Clinician16 (40)
 Methodologist17 (42.5)
 Methodologist/clinician6 (15)
 Consumer representative1 (2.5)
Geography
 Europe8 (20)
 United Kingdom4 (10)
 Canada4 (10)
 United States21 (52.5)
 South America1 (2.5)
 Africa1 (2.5)
 Asia1 (2.5)
Organization
 Academia/university20 (50)
 Government8 (20)
 Nongovernmental, nonacademic4 (10)
 Industry3 (7.5)
 Professional society5 (12.5)
Identification method
 Evidence-based medicine listserve15 (38)
 Guideline developers9 (23)
 Author contacts16 (40)