Abstract
A typical maternal and child health care program was implemented in an American Indian reservation community, and its impact on the effectiveness of prenatal care was assessed. Evaluation included examination from both the provider perspective (care provided to program users) and the population perspective (care received by a sample of all prenatal patients in the community), as well as examination of outcomes of prenatal care. The study cohorts were sorted into relatively high and average risk as a function of age, gravidity, and history of abortion or miscarriage. The study results suggest that such a program will improve the quality of prenatal care, although the program has a greater impact on the average risk group. Standard methods of assessing program effectiveness, which examine the care provided by the program as opposed to the care received by the community, will not detect this phenomenon.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Wallace HM, Gold EM, Lis EF (eds):—Maternal and Child Health Practices: Problems, Resources, and Methods of Delivery. Springfield, Ill, Charles C Thomas, 1973: pp. 243–258.
Nutting PA, Strotz CR, Shorr GI, et al: Reduction in gastroenteritis morbidity in high risk infants.Pediatrics 55:354–358, 1975.
Tatum W:The Papago Indian Reservation and The Papago People. Sells, Arizona, Papago Tribe of Arizona, 1974.
Garratt AE: A comprehensive health care data system.Computer Medicine 39–10, 1973.
Shorr GI, Nutting PA: A population-based assessment of the continuity of ambulatory care.Med Care 15455, 1977.
Shorr GI, Nutting PA, Berg LE:Quality Appraisal of Ambulatory Patient Care: An Eclectic Approach. Rockville, Md, National Center for Health Services Research, Grant No HS 01452-01, 1976.
Nutting PA, Shorr GI, Berg LE:Studies in Ambulatory Care Quality Assessment in the Indian Health Service, I: Overview of the Methodology. Tucson, Office of Research and Development, Indian Health Service, DHEW Publication No ORD SS1871, 1977.
Nutting PA, Helmick EF, Falvey RE, et al:Studies in Ambulatory Care Quality Assessment in the Indian Health Service, II: Appraisal of System Performance. Tucson, Office of Research and Development, Indian Health Service, DHEW Publication No ORD SS2971, 1977.
Nutting PA, Helmick EF, Falvey RE:Studies in Ambulatory Care Quality Assessment in the Indian Health Service, III: Comparison of Rural Private Practice, Health Maintenance Organizations, and the Indian Health Service. Tucson, Office of Research and Development, Indian Health Service, DHEW Publication No ORD SS3871, 1977.
Kessner DM, Kalk CE:Contrasts in Health Status Vol 2: A Strategy for Evaluating Health Service. Washington, DC, National Academy of Sciences, 1973.
Additional information
Dr. Nutting is Associate Director for Research in the Office of Research and Development, Indian Health Service, Box 11340, Tucson, Arizona 85734; Ms. Barrick and Ms. Logue are student research assistants. The authors wish to express their appreciation for the invaluable assistance of Mrs. Carol Koyawena, Mrs. Louise Burbank, and Ms. Hilda Antone in the preparation of this manuscript.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Nutting, P.A., Barrick, J.E. & Logue, S.C. The impact of a maternal and child health care program on the quality of prenatal care. J Community Health 4, 267–279 (1979). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01319021
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01319021