The power of nonspecific effects in healing: Implications for psychosocial and biological treatments

https://doi.org/10.1016/0272-7358(93)90010-JGet rights and content

Abstract

We evaluate the hypothesis that the power of nonspecific effects may account for as much as two thirds of successful treatment outcomes when both the healer and the patient believe in the efficacy of a treatment. Five medical and surgical treatments, once considered to be efficacious by their proponents but no longer considered effective based upon later controlled trials, were selected according to strict inclusion criteria. A search of the English literature was conducted for all studies published for each treatment area. The results of these studies were categorized, where possible, into excellent, good, and poor outcomes. For these five treatments combined, 40 % excellent, 30 % good, and 30 % poor results were reported by proponents. We conclude that, under conditions of heightened expectations, the power of nonspecific effects far exceeds that commonly reported in the literature. The implications of these results in evaluating the relative efficacy of biological and psychosocial treatments is discussed.

References (99)

  • J. Adno

    South African Medical Journal

    (1978)
  • E.A. Allcock et al.

    Structural changes following gasteric freezing

    Surgery

    (1963)
  • American Thoracic Society

    A statement by the committee on therapy

    American Review of Respiratory Disease

    (1968)
  • C.P. Artz et al.

    Clinical evaluation of gastric freezing for peptic ulcer

    Annals of Surgery

    (1964)
  • H.B. Barner et al.

    Clinical gastric “freezing”

    American Journal of Digestive Diseases

    (1966)
  • H.K. Beecher

    The powerful placebo

    Journal of the American Medical Association

    (1955)
  • H. Benson et al.

    The placebo effect: A neglected asset in the care of patients

    Journal of the American Medical Association

    (1975)
  • H. Benson et al.

    Angina pectoris and the placebo effect

    New England Journal of Medicine

    (1979)
  • E.F. Bernstein et al.

    Interim report on results of gastric freezing for peptic ulcer

    Journal of the American Medical Association

    (1964)
  • E.F. Bernstein et al.

    Treatment of postgastrectomy stomal ulcer by gastric freezing

    Archives of Surgery

    (1963)
  • L.E. Beutler

    Have all won and must all have prizes? Revisiting Luborsky et al.'s verdict

    Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology

    (1991)
  • T. Chang et al.

    Treatment with levamisole of recurrent herpes genitalis

    Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy

    (1978)
  • J.H. Comroe

    Resection of the carotid body for asthma

    Journal of the American Medical Association

    (1979)
  • L. Corey et al.

    Ineffectiveness of topical ether for the treatment of genital herpes simplex virus infection

    New England Journal of Medicine

    (1978)
  • W.S. Curran et al.

    Long term effects of glomectomy: Follow-up of a double-blind study

    American Review of Respiratory Disease

    (1971)
  • W.S. Curran et al.

    Glomectomy for severe bronchial asthma: A double-blind study

    American Review of Respiratory Disease

    (1966)
  • F.J. Evans

    The placebo response in pain reduction

    Advances in Neurology

    (1974)
  • F.J. Evans

    The power of a sugar pill

    Psychology Today

    (1974, April)
  • F.J. Evans

    Expectancy, therapeutic instructions, and the placebo response

  • T.D. Felber et al.

    Photoinactivation may find use against herpesvirus

    Journal of the American Medical Association

    (1971)
  • T.D. Felber et al.

    Photodynamic inactivation of herpes simples: Report of a clinical trial

    Journal of the American Medical Association

    (1973)
  • S. Fisher et al.

    The limits of biological treatments for psychological distress: Comparisons with psychotherapy and placebo

    (1989)
  • S. Fisher et al.

    A second opinion: Rethinking the claims of biological psychiatry

  • J.D. Frank et al.

    Persuasion and healing: A comparative study of psychotherapy

    (1991)
  • E.G. Friedrich

    Relief of herpes vulvitis

    Obstetrics and Gynecology

    (1973)
  • W.D. Gibbons

    Gastric hypothermia (Wangensteen): A preliminary report on cooling and “freezing” with the use of a new machine

    Medical Journal of Australia

    (1966)
  • M.E. Guinan et al.

    Topical ether and herpes simplex labialis

    Journal of the American Medical Association

    (1980)
  • P. Halttunen et al.

    Experiences with glomectomy in the treatment of bronchial asthma

    Annales Chirurgiae et Gynaecologiae Fenniae

    (1967)
  • R.W. Harjola et al.

    Reappraisal of Nakayama's carotid body resection for asthma

    Annales Chirurgiae et Gynaecologiae Fenniae

    (1968)
  • W.R. Harrell et al.

    Gastric hypothermia for duodenal ulcer: A long-term controlled study

    Journal of the American Medical Association

    (1967)
  • T.S. Heineken et al.

    Gastric freezing; Preliminary report on 10 cases

    American Journal of Gastroenterology

    (1963)
  • C.R. Hitchcock et al.

    Eighteen-month follow-up of gastric freezing in 173 patients with duodenal ulcer

    Journal of the American Medical Association

    (1966)
  • D.G. Jose et al.

    Levamisole in patients with recurrent herpes infection

    Medical Journal of Australia

    (1980)
  • S. Karacadag et al.

    Secretory comparison of gastric freezing and radiation therapy

    American Journal of Gastroenterology

    (1964)
  • R.H. Kaufman et al.

    Treatment of genital herpes simplex virus infection with photodynamic inactivation

    American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology

    (1978)
  • A. Kint et al.

    The treatment of recurrent herpes infections with levamisole

    Archives Belges de Dermatologica

    (1974)
  • A. Kint et al.

    Levamisole for recurrent herpes labialis

    New England Journal of Medicine

    (1974)
  • A. Kostelecky et al.

    Has glomectomy played any part in the treatment of bronchial asthma?

    International Surgery

    (1971)
  • E.B. Lefebvre et al.

    Photoinactivation of herpes simplex

    Journal of the American Medical Association

    (1973)
  • Cited by (0)

    View full text