Review and special articleEvaluating primary care behavioral counseling interventions: An evidence-based approach 1
Introduction
In 1998, the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) reconvened the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) to update its recommendations for clinical preventive services. This Task Force represents primary care disciplines (nursing, pediatrics, family practice, internal medicine, and obstetrics/gynecology), preventive medicine, and behavioral medicine. Two evidence-based practice centers (EPCs)—Oregon Health & Science University and the Research Triangle Institute/University of North Carolina—were contracted to prepare systematic evidence reviews that the Task Force uses in developing its recommendations for preventive care. Although the USPSTF evidence-based methods are widely applicable throughout medicine, to date they have been used primarily to assess services, such as preventive screening, rather than those requiring behavioral counseling.1, 2 The current Task Force recognized a twofold need: (1) to expand its evidence-based approach to better assess behavioral counseling interventions, and (2) to formulate practical communication strategies for describing services that are effective in changing behavior.
The Counseling and Behavioral Interventions Work Group of the USPSTF adapted the USPSTF generic screening analytic framework, which guides systematic reviews, to address behavioral topics more specifically, and it has promoted a consistent organizational construct for describing behavioral counseling interventions. Clinicians are referred to current products of the USPSTF (www.ahrq.gov/clinic/or 1-800-358-9295) for systematic evidence reviews of specific behavioral counseling topics and related USPSTF evidence-based recommendations and clinical considerations beyond the scope of this paper.
This paper has three purposes:
- 1.
To promote a broader appreciation of the importance of behavioral counseling interventions in clinical care and the context for their delivery.
- 2.
To describe the generic analytic frameworks developed to guide the systematic review of behavioral counseling topics for the third USPSTF.
- 3.
To detail the practical organizational construct (the Five A’s) adopted by the USPSTF to describe intervention research more consistently in order to foster its application in clinical settings.
Section snippets
Background
Healthy People 20103 sets two major goals for the United States: (1) to increase quality and years of healthy life, and (2) to eliminate health disparities among different segments of the population. The next decade offers unprecedented opportunities for healthcare systems and providers to address these goals by promoting healthy lifestyles among the diverse populations they serve and by adopting policies that will institutionalize preventive services.
Changing the health behaviors of Americans
Rationale for behavioral counseling interventions in clinical care
Healthcare providers and their staff play a unique and important role in motivating and assisting patients’ healthy behavior changes. Patients report that primary care clinicians are expected sources of preventive health information and recommendations for patients.30 For instance, in a recent survey, the vast majority (92% to 98%) of adult members of health maintenance organizations indicated that they expected advice and help from the healthcare system in key behaviors, such as diet,
Objectives and scope of behavioral counseling interventions
Behavioral counseling interventions in clinical care are those activities delivered by primary care clinicians and related healthcare staff to assist patients in adopting, changing, or maintaining behaviors proven to affect health outcomes and health status. Common health-promoting behaviors include smoking cessation, healthy diet, regular physical activity, appropriate alcohol use, and responsible use of contraceptives.
Behavioral counseling interventions occur all or in part during routine
The potential impact of health behavior–change programs in clinical care
Appreciating behavioral counseling interventions requires a true population-based medicine perspective (i.e., intervening with individuals, but recognizing that the health benefits may not be as clinically visible individually as they are clinically meaningful when considered for the whole). Individually, brief behavioral counseling interventions that are feasible in healthcare settings often have only modest behavior change impacts. For example, only 5% to 15% of those receiving an
Practical approaches to overcome barriers to behavioral and counseling interventions
Numerous barriers to preventive service delivery continue to exist in present-day healthcare settings, most of which are still organized mainly around symptom-driven, acute illness care.67, 68 These barriers include a focus on more medically urgent issues; lack of time; inadequate clinician training, self-confidence, or reimbursement; low patient demand; and lack of supportive resources.3, 69 Further, feedback to clinicians about results of preventive care is largely non-existent or can even be
Evidence-based methods for evaluating behavioral counseling interventions
We developed two interrelated generic analytic frameworks to guide the systematic review of behavioral topics Figure 1, Figure 2. These analytic frameworks were derived from those developed for screening topics.2 They separately frame the two main questions to consider when systematically reviewing relevant clinical behavioral intervention research, namely: (1) Does changing individual health behavior improve health outcomes? Figure 1, Figure 2 Can interventions in the clinical setting
Background
The Four A’s construct (ask, advise, assist, arrange) was originally developed by the National Cancer Institute to guide physician intervention in smoking cessation.103 Recently, the Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care proposed that clinicians use a Five A’s construct (adding an agree step) to organize their general approach to assisting patients with behavioral counseling issues (W. Elford, Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care, personal communication, December 2000). The
Conclusions
Behavioral counseling interventions in clinical settings are an important means of addressing prevalent health-related behaviors, such as lack of physical activity, poor diet, substance (tobacco, alcohol, and illicit drug) use and dependence, and risky sexual behavior that underlie a substantial proportion of preventable morbidity and mortality in the United States. Important advances in the ways primary care interventions have been packaged have resulted from the past 2 decades of research.
Acknowledgements
This work was produced by the Oregon Health & Science University Evidence-Based Practice Center, under contract to the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (contract No. 290-97-0018), Rockville, Maryland.
We gratefully acknowledge early manuscript review and suggestions by outside experts Sue Curry, PhD; Russ Glasgow, PhD; Michael Goldstein, MD; and Pat Mullen, DrPH; as well as the support and critical review by other members of the work group (Karen Eden, PhD; Mark Helfand, MD, MPH; Peter
References (138)
- et al.
Current methods of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Forcea review of the process
Am J Prev Med
(2001) - et al.
Self-report of delivery of clinical preventive services by U.S. physicians. Comparing specialty, gender, age, setting of practice, and area of practice
Am J Prev Med
(1999) - et al.
Interactive communication strategiesimplications for population-based physical-activity promotion
Am J Prev Med
(2000) - et al.
Interactive health communication in preventive medicineInternet-based strategies in teaching and research
Am J Prev Med
(2000) - et al.
Counselingimplementing our knowledge in a hurried and complex world
Am J Prev Med
(1999) - et al.
Will patient satisfaction set the preventive services implementation agenda?
Am J Prev Med
(1997) - et al.
Direct observation of exercise counseling in community family practice
Am J Prev Med
(1999) - et al.
Scope and organization of the Guide to Community Preventive Services. The Task Force on Community Preventive Services
Am J Prev Med
(2000) What is counseling all about—basics in the counseling of health-related physical activity
Patient Educ Couns
(1998)- et al.
Theories and intervention approaches to health-behavior change in primary care
Am J Prev Med
(1999)
Motivational interviewing in health care settingsopportunities and limitations
Am J Prev Med
A randomized trial of a tailored, self-help dietary interventionthe Puget Sound Eating Patterns Study
Prev Med
A stage paradigm for integrating clinical and public health approaches to smoking cessation
Addict Behav
Health promotion in primary carea survey of U.S. family practitioners
Prev Med
Physician training for patient-centered nutrition counseling in a lipid intervention trial
Prev Med
Training physicians to conduct physical activity counseling
Prev Med
Will primary care clinics organize themselves to improve the delivery of preventive services? A randomized controlled trial
Prev Med
A clinical trial of tailored office systems for preventive service deliverythe Study to Enhance Prevention by Understanding Practice (STEP-UP)
Am J Prev Med
Interactive technology applications for behavioral counselingissues and opportunities for health care settings
Am J Prev Med
Broadening the evidence base for evidence-based guidelinesa research agenda based on the work of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force
Am J Prev Med
Healthy People 2010
Health promotion and disease prevention in clinical practice
Actual causes of death in the United States
JAMA
Healthy people 2000 review
Baseline data on the delivery of clinical preventive services provided by nurse practitioners
Nurse Pract
Why invest in disease prevention?
A systematic review of the effectiveness of promoting lifestyle change in general practice
Fam Pract
Treating tobacco use and dependencea clinical practice guideline
Screening for problem drinking and counseling by the primary care physician-nurse team
Alcohol Clin Exp Res
Attributes of successful smoking cessation interventions in medical practicea meta-analysis of 39 controlled trials
JAMA
A cross-national trial of brief interventions with heavy drinkers
Am J Public Health
Meta-analysis of randomized control trials addressing brief interventions in heavy alcohol drinkers
J Gen Intern Med
Brief interventions for alcohol problemsa review
Addiction
A meta-analysis of trials evaluating patient education and counseling for three groups of preventive health behaviors
Patient Educ Couns
Can dietary interventions change diet and cardiovascular risk factors? A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
Am J Public Health
Effectiveness of physician-based interventions with problem drinkersa review
Can Med Assoc J
Brief physician advice for problem alcohol drinkersa randomized controlled trial in community-based primary care practices
JAMA
Telephone quitlines for smoking cessation
Randomized trial of a brief dietary intervention to decrease consumption of fat and increase consumption of fruit and vegetables
Am J Health Promotion
Self-help materials
One size does not fit allthe case for tailoring print materials
Ann Behav Med
The medical care system and preventionthe need for a new paradigm
HMO Pract
The physician’s role in health promotion revisited—a survey of primary care practitioners
N Engl J Med
Health promotionphysicians’ beliefs, attitudes, and practices
Am J Prev Med
The physician’s role in health-promotion and disease prevention
Bull N Y Acad Med
Health and nutrition, no. 195visits to office based physicians, 1996
Cited by (788)
Content Validition and Psychometric Evaluation of the Self-efficacy and Performance in Self-management Support Instrument for Physiotherapists
2024, Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation2022 ACC/AHA guideline for the diagnosis and management of aortic disease: A report of the American Heart Association/American College of Cardiology Joint Committee on Clinical Practice Guidelines
2023, Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular SurgeryPrimary Care Treatment Integrating Motivation and Exposure for PTSD Symptoms and Hazardous Alcohol Use: A Case Series
2023, Cognitive and Behavioral PracticeThe Healthy Kids & Families study: Outcomes of a 24-month childhood obesity prevention intervention
2023, Preventive Medicine Reports2022 ACC/AHA Guideline for the Diagnosis and Management of Aortic Disease: A Report of the American Heart Association/American College of Cardiology Joint Committee on Clinical Practice Guidelines
2022, Journal of the American College of Cardiology
- 1
The full text of this article is available via AJPM Online at www.ajpm-online.net.