Elsevier

Midwifery

Volume 16, Issue 2, June 2000, Pages 145-154
Midwifery

Regular Article
Does continuity of carer matter to women from minority ethnic groups?

https://doi.org/10.1054/midw.2000.0204Get rights and content

Abstract

Objective: to explore the maternity care views and experiences of minority ethnic women who did not respond to a postal survey of mothers' responses to care and to assess whether the concept of continuity mattered to them.

Design: a semi-structured narrative interview, at about six months following birth, designed to encourage women to describe their experiences of pregnancy, birth and maternity care in their own words and according to their own perspectives.

Setting: maternity care in a London NHS Trust with two teaching hospital units, where women in a specific neighbourhood received caseload midwifery care as part of a pilot scheme and other women received conventional (normally ‘shared’) maternity care.

Participants: 20 women, half receiving caseload midwifery care and half conventional maternity care.

Measurements and findings: the interviews were transcribed in full and the texts analysed by open coding and grouping into conceptual areas and linking themes. Key findings related to continuity of carer are highlighted in this paper but related concepts, such as that of control will be reported in more detail elsewhere. Although detailed views and requirements were specific to these women, underlying values and priorities were similar to those reported widely in consumer research in maternity care. The women valued concepts such as communication, support, and control highly but those receiving conventional care were disappointed with their care, particularly in hospital settings and did not feel it was focused on them as a person. Women receiving caseload midwifery care held more positive views and emphasised the role of having ‘their own’ midwife in supporting such concepts. They showed greater trust and confidence in the professionals and in the personal transition of giving birth.

Key conclusions: this small study adds to an existing body of evidence that minority ethnic women do not receive a high quality of maternity care in conventional services and suggests that this is related to the institutional organisation of care. It does not support the assumption that the principles of Changing Childbirth, in particular that of continuity of carer, do not matter to them. Conversely, this group of women shared similar fundamental values and hopes of the service with the wider population of which they are a part but experience a greater dissonance between expectations and experience.

Implications for practice: organisation of maternity care should make caseload midwifery available as a choice for such women to facilitate more woman-centred care.

References (66)

  • J Green et al.

    Stereotypes of childbearing women: a look at some evidence

    Midwifery

    (1990)
  • C Murray-Parkes

    Psycho-social transitions, a field for study

    Social Science and Medicine

    (1971)
  • W Arney

    Power and the profession of obstetrics

    (1982)
  • J Ball

    Reactions to motherhood: the role of postnatal care

    (1994)
  • S Beake et al.

    The use of clinical audit in evaluating maternity services reform: a critical reflection

    Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice

    (1998)
  • AM Bowes et al.

    Pakistani women and maternity care: raising muted voices

    Sociology of Health & Illness

    (1996)
  • I Bowler

    ‘They're not the same as us’: midwives stereo-types of South Asian descent maternity patients

    Sociology of Health and Illness

    (1993)
  • H Bradby

    Ethnicity: not a black and white issue. A research note

    Sociology of Health & Illness

    (1995)
  • A Cartwright

    The Dignity of Labour? A study of childbearing and induction

    (1979)
  • R Davis-Floyd

    The ritual of hospital birth in America

  • Changing Childbirth: the Report of the Expert Maternity Group

    (1993)
  • J Douglas

    Black Women's health matters: putting black women on the research agenda

  • English National Board for Nursing, Midwifery & Health Visiting, 1998, Research and development projects for...
  • J Garcia

    Continuity of carer in context: what matters to women?

  • J Garcia et al.

    First class delivery: a national survey of women's views of maternity care

    (1998)
  • K Gerrish et al.

    Nursing for a multi-ethnic society

    (1996)
  • F Ginsberg et al.

    Conceiving the new world order

    The global politics of reproduction

    (1995)
  • B Glaser et al.

    The discovery of grounded theory

    (1967)
  • S Gluck et al.

    Women's words

    The feminist practice of oral history

    (1991)
  • J Green et al.

    Great expectations: a prospective study of women's expectations and experiences of childbirth

    (1988)
  • J Green et al.

    Continuing to care: the organisation of midwifery services in the UK: a structured review of the evidence

    (1998)
  • H Handler et al.

    Women's satisfaction with prenatal care settings: a focus group study

    Birth

    (1996)
  • Harper-Bulman, K, McCourt, C, 1997, Report on Somali women's experiences of maternity care, Centre for Midwifery...
  • L Hayes

    Unequal access to midwifery care: a continuing problem?

    Journal of Advanced Nursing

    (1995)
  • J Hirst et al.

    Antenatal care: what do women want?

  • House of Commons Health Committee, 1992, Maternity Services: Government Response to the Second Report from the Health...
  • A Jacoby et al.

    Finding out about the views and experiences of maternity service users

  • B Jordan

    Birth in four cultures: a crosscultural investigation of childbirth in Yucatan, Holland, Sweden and the United States

    (1993)
  • M Kirkham

    Midwives and information giving during labour

  • M Kirkham

    Communication in midwifery

  • M Kirkham

    Professionalisation past and present: with women or with the powers that be?

  • M Kirkham

    Stories and childbirth

  • Cited by (69)

    • Better together: A qualitative exploration of women's perceptions and experiences of group antenatal care

      2019, Women and Birth
      Citation Excerpt :

      Lack of engagement with antenatal care and belonging to socially, ethnically or linguistically marginalised groups has been associated with adverse pregnancy outcomes including low birth-weight, neonatal mortality and maternal morbidity and mortality.5,6 There is evidence that routine maternity care in an obstetric-led service, despite the aims of midwifery care, may alienate or disempower women, particularly those from minority groups.7,8 Globally, there is a drive to improve health outcomes for childbearing women in disadvantaged communities through facilitating both their access to care, particularly in the antenatal period, and their empowerment.9,10

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    f1

    Correspondence to CM

    f2

    [email protected]

    View full text