Article Figures & Data
Tables
Characteristic Value Sex, No. (%) Male 979 (42.1) Female 1,349 (57.9) Age, No. (%) 18-29 years 409 (17.6) 30-44 years 566 (24.3) 45-59 years 611 (26.2) ≥60 years 742 (31.9) Age, mean (SD) [range], y 49.2 (17.4) Educational attainment, No. (%) No high school diploma 186 (8.0) High school diploma 524 (22.5) Some college 863 (37.1) Bachelor’s degree or higher 755 (32.4) Educational attainment,a mean (SD), y 12.7 (2.01) Household income, No. (%) <150% FPL 873 (37.5) 150%-399% FPL 797 (34.2) ≥400% FPL 658 (28.3) Ethnicity/race, No. (%) Non-Hispanic Black 704 (30.2) Hispanic 711 (30.5) Non-Hispanic White 913 (39.2) Has primary care provider, No. (%) No 405 (17.4) Yes 1,919 (82.6) Self-rated health status, No. (%) Excellent 240 (10.3) Very good 814 (35.1) Good 841 (36.2) Fair 350 (15.0) Poor 77 (3.3) Self-rated health,b mean (SD) 2.49 (0.66) Medical mistrust,c No. (%) A lot of trust 971 (43.0) Some trust 980 (43.4) Not at all/not too much trust 306 (13.6) - Table 2.
Bivariate Associations Between Perceived Discrimination and Race/Ethnicity (N = 2,328)
Perceived Discrimination Survey Item Race/Ethnicity P Value No/Yes Hispanic, No. (%) Non-Hispanic Black, No. (%) Non-Hispanic White, No. (%) Perceived discrimination because of income, or type, or lack of insurance Have you ever felt judged or treated differently by a health care provider because of your income? No 603 (88) 581 (82) 817 (90) .001 Yes 82 (12) 132 (19) 90 (10) Have you ever felt judged or treated differently by a health care provider because of the type of insurance you have? No 576 (84) 521 (73) 775 (85) .001 Yes 116 (16) 196 (27) 133 (15) Have you ever felt judged or treated differently by a health care provider because of being uninsured? No 609 (88) 575 (81) 821 (91) .001 Yes 82 (12) 135 (19) 80 (9) Have you ever felt like you could not get health care services you needed because of your income? No 513 (74) 504 (71) 720 (79) .001 Yes 513 (26) 208 (29) 187 (21) Have you ever felt like you could not get health care services you needed because of the type of insurance you have? No 491 (71) 477 (67) 707 (78) .001 Yes 203 (29) 238 (33) 200 (22) Have you ever felt like you could not get health care services you needed because of being uninsured? No 509 (73) 531 (75) 762 (84) .001 Yes 186 (27) 181 (25) 144 (16) Perceived discrimination because of race/ethnicity or language spoken Have you ever felt judged or treated differently by a health care provider because of your race or ethnicity? No 620 (89) 499 (70) 874 (97) .001 Yes 74 (11) 216 (30) 29 (3) Have you ever felt judged or treated differently by a health care provider because of your language? No 623 (90) 666 (94) 889 (98) .001 Yes 69 910) 40 (6) 14 (2) Have you ever felt like you could not get health care services you needed because of your race or ethnicity? No 636 (92) 579 (81) 892 (98) .001 Yes 53 (8) 136 (19) 17 (2) Have you ever felt like you could not get health care services you needed because of your language? No 624 (91) 674 (95) 898 (99) .001 Yes 63 (9) 33 (5) 10 (1) - Table 3.
Bivariate Associations Between Participant Characteristics and Level of Trust (N = 2,257)
Characteristic Level of Trust P Value A Lot Some Not at All or Not Too Much Sex, No. (%) <.001 Male 449 (48) 361 (38) 133 (14) Female 522 (40) 619 (47) 173 (13) Age, mean (SD), y 54.5 (17.95) 46.4 (16.44) 42.3 (14.10) <.001 Education, mean (SD) 10.6 (1.92) 10.2 (2.06) 10.1 (2.07) <.001 Household income, No. (%) <.001 <150% FPL 312 (37) 374 (45) 150 (18) 150%-399% FPL 321 (42) 348 (45) 100 (13) ≥400% FPL 338 (52) 258 (39) 56 (9) Ethnicity/race, No. (%) <.001 Non-Hispanic Black 259 (37) 332 (47) 113 (16) Hispanic 236 (36) 311 (47) 115 (17) Non-Hispanic White 476 (53) 337 (38) 78 (9) Primary care provider, No. (%) <.001 No 54 (16) 171 (49) 123 (35) Yes 917 (48) 807 (42) 183 (10) Self-rated health status, mean (SD) 2.49 (0.96) 2.68 (0.91) 3.02 (1.02) <.001 Perceived discrimination due to income and type of or lack of insurance, mean (SD)a –0.27 (0.80) 0.07 (1.01) 0.61 (1.19) <.001 Perceived racial and language-related discrimination, mean (SD)a –0.07 (0.80) –0.01 (0.98) 0.27 (1.45) <.001 FPL = federal poverty level.
Notes: Sample size reflects 71 missing cases. Refer to Table 1 for measurement scales.
↵a A higher score indicates a higher level of perceived discrimination.
- Table 4.
Multivariate Associations Between Participant Characteristics and Trust (N = 2,257)
Characteristic Level of Trusta A Lot Some aOR (95% CI) P Value aOR (95% CI) P Value Sex Male 1.09 (0.79-1.50) .59 1.41 (1.04-1.90) <.05 Female (ref) 1.00 1.00 Age, per year 0.97 (0.96-0.98) <.001 0.99 (0.98-1.00) .10 Educational attainment, y 0.98 (0.90-1.07) .66 1.02 (0.95-1.11) .57 Household Income <150% FPL 1.03 (0.66-1.60) .90 1.30 (0.85-1.98) .23 150%-399% FPL 1.09 (0.76-1.55) .64 1.36 (0.98-1.90) .07 ≥400% FPL (ref) 1.00 1.00 Race/ethnicity Non-Hispanic Black 1.73 (1.15-2.61) <.01 1.32 (0.89-1.95) .17 Hispanic 1.49 (1.02-2.17) <.05 1.29 (0.91-1.82) .15 Non-Hispanic White (ref) 1.00 1.00 Primary care provider No 7.56 (5.06-11.30) <.000 2.76 (2.01-3.78) <.001 Yes (ref) 1.00 1.00 Self-rated healthb 1.68 (1.43-1.98) <.001 1.39 (1.20-1.62) <.001 Perceived discrimination due to income and type of or lack of insurance 1.98 (1.71-2.29) <.001 1.41 (1.24-1.59) <.001 Perceived racial or language-related discrimination 1.25 (1.10-1.43) <.001 1.19 (1.06-1.33) <.003 aOR = adjusted odds ratio; FPL = federal poverty level; ref = reference group.
Notes: Sample size reflects 71 missing cases; multinomial logistic regression analysis. The –2 log likelihood was 3,740; degrees of freedom = 22; Nagelkerke = 0.234.
↵a Reference category is not at all/not too much trust.
↵b Scale of 1 to 5, excellent to poor.
Additional Files
The Article in Brief
Discrimination and Medical Mistrust in a Racially and Ethnically Diverse Sample of California Adults
Mohsen Bazargan , and colleagues
Background Medical mistrust is a major barrier to a strong patient-clinician relationship. For racial/ethnic minorities, medical mistrust may be rooted in patients' past experience of discrimination. Understanding the mechanisms of these racial differences may lead to better optimization of therapeutic effectiveness and decreased patient mistrust.
What This Study Found Researchers at the Charles R. Drew University in Los Angeles analyzed data from more than 2,300 White, Hispanic, and non-Hispanic Black adults who asked to report on perceived discrimination due to race, ethnicity, language, income, and insurance status or type. Black and Hispanic adults reported higher rates of discrimination across the board, including income and insurance-based discrimination. Black and Hispanic adults reported higher rates of discrimination, including income and insurance-based discrimination. In addition, 20% and 10% of Black and Latino adults stated that they could not get health care services they needed because of racial/ethnic or language discrimination, respectively. The analysis also found a link between having a consistent primary care physician and overall medical trust. Adults who did not have a usual source of primary care were much more likely to report mistrust of health care providers.
Implications
- The research team discusses the link between medical mistrust, racial and ethnic discrimination in health care, and roots in institutionalized racism, declaring that, "resolving mistrust requires addressing systemic bias and prejudice in the medical system," echoing recent sentiments expressed by the American Medical Association.